Saturday, April 13, 2019

When is Time Really "Of the Essence"

WHEN IS TIME REALLY "OF THE ESSENCE"
 
We can probably all agree that time is a precious commodity in short supply during the course of our working day. We change the clock in March of each year to make better use of daylight hours and preserve energy; yet, we complain that this annual event negatively impacts our time to sleep. As real estate professionals we encounter the issue of time when clients tell us they are not ready to sign a contract of sale because the due diligence period is not completed, the buyer has to liquidate funds for the requisite contract deposit, the bank has not issued a loan commitment within the time period required in the contract of sale, the seller cannot close when anticipated because the property she is purchasing has met some unexpected delays or the buyer would rather close at the end of the month so as to not incur additional per diem mortgage interest. No matter what the excuse or the reasoning behind the request of a party for additional time, the agent invariably encounters the question asked by the client "how much time do I have before I am forced to close." The manner by which the agent answers that question will determine if both the agent and the firm will be subject to future litigation.
 
In a contract for the sale of real property in New York State, it is well settled that unless the contract specifically adds the statement in the closing date paragraph "time being of the essence" it is understood that neither party can force the closing on that date. In effect, "time is not assumed to be of the essence..." unless the parties have specifically so stated. Many agents mistakenly believe that a party to a contract of sale cannot compel a closing for at least thirty days from the closing date paragraph. If the agent informs the client that this is so and the client relies to his or her detriment based on that information, the agent and the brokerage firm can be held accountable for any loss sustained by the client if the other party initiates a breach of contract action. While many real estate attorneys also believe that custom and usage in the industry permit an adjournment of a closing for up to thirty days, there is no statutory or case law to support this position. Although one party to a contract may not unilaterally make time of the essence without reasonable and sufficient notice to the other party, time may be made of the essence by "clear, distinct and unequivocal notice to that effect giving the other party a reasonable time in which to act." While there is no statutory guideline as to what is "reasonable" under the circumstances, the courts throughout New York State have provided guidance in this regard, albeit with no hard and fast interpretation.
 
Let's review some recent court cases in an attempt to get a better understanding of what may be reasonable when a party requests an adjournment of the closing date. In 2017, the Appellate Division, First Department examined the case of a purchaser who brought an action seeking the return of its deposit on the purchase of a commercial condominium unit and the Court held that the seller breached the contract of sale by failing to close by the date specified by the purchaser when the purchaser unilaterally set "time of the essence" after the date specified in the contract of sale and the purchaser's letter giving the seller a thirty day notice was sufficient to make the closing date "time of the essence." Contrast this case with a 2018 case from the Appellate Division, Second Department where the seller's unilateral setting of the closing giving nine days' notice to the purchaser was deemed sufficient. The Court reasoned "When, as here, a contract for the sale of real property does not make time ofthe essence, the law permits a reasonable time in which to tender performance, regardless of whether the contract designates a specific date for performance...Where there is an indefinite adjournment of the closing date specified in the contract of sale, some affirmative act has to be taken by one party before [it] can claim the other party is in default; that is, one party has to fix a time by which the other must perform, and [it] must inform the other that if [it] does not perform by that date, [it] will be considered in default."
 
What constitutes a reasonable time for performance depends upon the facts and circumstances of each particular case. Neither an agent nor an attorney can use a broad brush and inform a client that in all instances, an adjournment of up to thirty days from the date specified in the contract of sale is reasonable. This simply is not the proper way to address the client's concerns. Included within a court's determination of reasonableness are the nature and object of the contract, the previous conduct of the parties, the presence or absence of good faith, the experience of the parties and the possibility of prejudice or hardship to either one, as well as the specific number of days provided for performance. As many courts have opined, "The determination of reasonableness must by its very nature be determined on a case-by-case basis." The question of what constitutes a reasonable time is usually a question of fact to be determined by a judge or jury.
 
It has been my practice for the past thirty-five years to inform my clients, be they sellers or purchasers, that the closing date in the contract of sale should reflect the comfort level of the clients in being able to complete the transaction and that although the clients cannot be forced to close on or by that date, they could be compelled to close in as little as one week after the closing date or as late as several weeks thereafter...there is no clear cut formula to employ and the deciding factor on what is "reasonable" may very well depend on circumstances beyond the clients' control. If the attorney representing the other party to the transaction believes that a "reasonable adjournment" of the closing date is thirty days, then my clients will be given up to thirty days to adjourn; however, if the other party to the transaction cannot and will not afford my clients that much additional time, the other party does have the means to unilaterally set a closing date much earlier with the proper notification that "time is of the essence."  
 
As I have recommended "time and time" again in articles to the real estate brokerage community, one should always attempt to shift the risk when given the opportunity to do so. If you are asked by your client to identify the outside date for a closing, rather than respond with an answer that may lead the client to make arrangements that will invariably put the client in harm's way, always suggest that the client speak with his or her attorney to better understand the nuances in answering this question. To do otherwise will subject both the agent and the brokerage firm to potential liability, so direct yourself accordingly.
Alfred M. Fazio, Esq.
Capuder Fazio Giacoia LLP 
90 Broad Street 
New York, N.Y.  10004-2627  
212-509-9595

New York State New Transfer and Mansion Tax Law


REAL ESTATE AGENTS-
TRANSFER AND MANSION TAX INCREASES WILL AFFECT
YOUR CLIENTS' TRANSACTION COSTS
Effective July 1, 2019, all real estate closings in the State of New York will be affected by the recent increases in the transfer and mansion taxes but the new law will not apply to conveyances made pursuant to binding contracts entered into on or before April 1, 2019 even if the transaction closes after July 1, 2019. The purchaser and/or seller will have to prove the date of execution by independent evidence such as a recorded contract, payment of a deposit on contract or other facts and circumstances determined by the NYS Commissioner of Taxation and Finance.
Clearly, when you are discussing the costs to be incurred by a seller or a purchaser ready to enter into a contract of sale, it is imperative that you provide your client/customer with accurate information and knowing the particulars of the new tax laws imposed by New York State is of the utmost importance. As an attorney practicing transactional real estate, I am responsible to inform my clients of all anticipated closing costs associated with their purchase or sale and in my humble opinion, it is your responsibility to do the same. Obviously, the seller should understand the costs to be incurred in order to determine whether a submitted offer is financially viable and likewise, a purchaser should be advised of anticipated closing costs to determine if there are sufficient assets on hand to support the offer. I want to thank my colleagues at Regal Title Agency for providing me with the particulars of the new tax laws so that I can equip my readers with the information necessary to better serve their clients and/or customers.
1. The increase in the NYS transfer tax only applies to cities in NYS with a population of one million residents or more (i.e. New York City)
2. The basic transfer tax (normally, payable by Seller) is presently four dollars per thousand ($2.00 per five hundred or "fractional part thereof"). As of July 1, 2019, for certain transfers the tax will be increased to
A. An additional $1.25 for each $500.00 ($2.50 per $1,000.00) on all conveyances of residential Real Property when the consideration is $3,000,000.00 or more - "Residential Real Property shall include "any premises that that is or may be used in whole or in part as a personal residence, and shall include a one, two, or three-family house, an individual condominium unit or a cooperative unit"; and

B. On all other conveyances (i.e. not Residential Real Property) when the consideration is $2,000,000.00 or more.  

3. The Mansion Tax (normally payable by the buyer), is presently one percent on conveyances of Residential Real Property (as defined above) when the consideration is $1,000,000.00 or more on one to three family dwellings, cooperative and condominium units. There is now a supplemental Mansion Tax (only applicable for cities of One million residents or more ) that increases as the consideration for the conveyance increases.  
ConsiderationNew York Mansion Tax (including Supplemental Mansion tax)
$1,000,000.00 or lessNot subject to tax
$1,000,000.00, to 1,999,999.991%
$2,000,000.00 to 2,999,999.991.25%
$3,000,000.00 to 4,999,999.991.5%
$5,000,000.00 to $9,999,999.992.25%
$10,000,000.00 to $14,999,999.993.25%
$15,000,000.00 to $19,999,999.993.5%
$20,000,000.00 to $24,999,999.993.75%
$25,000,000.00 or more3.9%
            4. The New Transfer and Mansion tax rates take effect on July 1, 2019, for conveyances occurring on or after July 1, 2019.   If you close after the effective date but can prove you entered into a binding contract as confirmed by independent evidence such as the recording of the contract, payment of the contract deposit or other facts and circumstances, determined by the Commissioner of Taxation and Finance, the parties will be permitted to pay the current rates.   If you enter into a contract today, but close, record and pay the transfer tax by June 30, 2019, you will be charged the current rate, not the increased rate. 
Hopefully this will serve as motivation for all agents to familiarize themselves with closing costs associated with real estate transactions and to educate their clients/customers of these costs in advance of taking a listing on behalf of a seller or presenting an offer on behalf of a purchaser, so direct yourself accordingly.
   
Alfred M. Fazio, Esq.
Capuder Fazio Giacoia LLP 
90 Broad Street 
New York, N.Y.  10004-2627  
212-509-9595


















CALL / EMAIL ME! I'M HERE FOR ALL YOUR REAL ESTATE NEEDS!
C: 212-321-0115
E: NYCTREALTY@GMAIL.COM

Fernando Branco, GRI, ABR, CNE
Lic. Assoc. Real Estate Broker
Residential Real Estate
Commercial Sales & Leasing 
Graduate Realtor Institute (GRI) 
Accredited Buyer Representative (ABR) 
Certified Negotiator Expert (CNE)
R New York
641 Lexington Ave, NY NY  10022
c: (212) 321-0115

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Blogger Facebook Page Google Plus Google Plus Page 

Working by referral. Let me help you find a home too!!

Monday, March 4, 2019

NYC Megaprojects / NYC 25 Most Expensive Homes / 220 Central Park South / Hudson Yards Tallest Tower / Paul Rudolph's $18M Townhouse / Martha Stewart's Daughter $53M WV Triplex / Eleanor Roosevelt's UES Townhouse

Insert alt text here
A guide to the major megaprojects transforming New York City
Entire stretches of New York City are giving rise to new and recreated neighborhoods, from the World Trade Center to Willets Point.
Insert alt text here
NYC’s 25 most expensive homes for sale
Here now, check New York's biggest listings—with starchitect-designed penthouses, historic townhouses, and glorious old co-ops among them.
Insert alt text here
First look inside 220 Central Park SouthThe 40th-floor apartment has three bedrooms and Central Park views
Insert alt text here
35 Hudson Yards, the NYC megaproject’s tallest condo tower, will launch sales next weekApartments within the "more upscale" building start at $5 million
Insert alt text here
Paul Rudolph’s modernist Beekman Place townhouse lists for $18.5MThe Midtown townhouse is where Rudolph lived for much of his life
Insert alt text here
One of 443 Greenwich Street’s massive penthouses is back for $57M
The triplex apartment comes with its own private rooftop pool. 
Insert alt text here
Martha Stewart’s daughter lists huge West Village triplex for $53MAlexis Stewart pieced together the apartment, located in a celeb-friendly West Village Building, from several separate units
Insert alt text here
Eleanor Roosevelt’s historic Upper East Side townhouse lists for $13.5MThe former First Lady lived in an apartment in the townhouse from 1953 to 1958
Insert alt text here
Rent on Annie Leibovitz’s former West Village compound for $12,600/monthThe townhouse is one of the West Village’s prettiest homes
CALL / EMAIL ME! I'M HERE FOR ALL YOUR REAL ESTATE NEEDS!
C: 212-321-0115
E: NYCTREALTY@GMAIL.COM

Fernando Branco, GRI, ABR, CNE
Lic. Assoc. Real Estate Broker
Residential Real Estate
Commercial Sales & Leasing 
Graduate Realtor Institute (GRI) 
Accredited Buyer Representative (ABR) 
Certified Negotiator Expert (CNE)
R New York
641 Lexington Ave, NY NY  10022
c: (212) 321-0115

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Blogger Facebook Page Google Plus Google Plus Page 

Working by referral. Let me help you find a home too!!

Saturday, February 2, 2019

WHEN IS A COMMITMENT LETTER NOT A BANK COMMITMENT: WHEN THE PURCHASER FORFEITS THE DEPOSIT BECAUSE OF IT

WHEN IS A COMMITMENT LETTER NOT A BANK COMMITMENT:
WHEN THE PURCHASER FORFEITS THE DEPOSIT BECAUSE OF IT
 
All real estate agents and purchasers beware!! In residential real estate transactions where financing is involved and the contract of sale is contingent on the purchaser's ability to obtain financing (of course there are transactions which allow the purchaser to obtain financing that do not provide for a contingency), it is imperative the purchaser and the buyer's agent understand the complexities of the mortgage clause in the contract of sale.
 
The purchaser has been pre-approved by a lender and the transaction is well on its way to a successful conclusion depending on the application review by the cooperative corporation or condominium board of managers, if applicable. True to her word, the lender issues a commitment within forty-five days of the contract execution. Unfortunately for the purchaser, seller and the real estate agents, the commitment is anything but what it claims to be because it is subject to several conditions, one of which includes the review of the finances of the condominium or cooperative building. In all financed transactions including one to three family dwellings, the lender's commitment will be contingent upon a satisfactory bank appraisal and there will be conditions where the lender will seek to verify assets, income and continued employment. Unfortunately, within the next two weeks you learn that the commitment was rescinded by the lender because of the building's finances or possibly because the purchaser's employment or asset base changed between application and closing. The purchaser's attorney sends the letter of declination to the seller's attorney expecting the return of the contract deposit; however, the seller's attorney responds that unless the purchaser attends the closing and pays what is required according to the contract terms, the purchaser will be held in default and forfeit the contract deposit.
 
Pursuant to the standard form residential contract, a commitment which is conditional upon any factor other than an appraisal is considered a firm commitment and the purchaser cannot cancel the contract. Once a commitment is issued by the lender, whether two days after contract signing or two months later, if the lender does not complete the transaction for any reason other than a below market appraisal which causes the lender to reduce the principal amount of the mortgage to an amount less than what is stated in the contract, the purchaser can be held in default and lose her deposit. Even if the commitment letter is issued and not delivered to the seller's attorney, the terms of the standard form of contract mandates that the commitment is nonetheless deemed issued and the risk is entirely on the side of the purchaser.
 
The parties need to understand the difference between a mortgage or loan contingency and a funding contingency. Many attorneys representing prospective purchasers attempt to modify the standard language to allow the purchaser to terminate the contract and obtain the return of the deposit if and when the lender rescinds a commitment after it is issued; however, most attorneys who represent sellers will not agree to modify the provision to allow for a funding contingency. In effect, if the bank issues the commitment and the bank chooses to not fund the loan, the risk is on the side of the purchaser. If the purchaser's financial status changes after the commitment is issued or if the building's finances are downgraded by the bank, the seller would have the right to claim the contract deposit as liquidated damages unless there is specific language in the contract that provides the purchaser the right to terminate the contract with the return of the deposit.
 
In every transaction where I represent a purchaser, considerable time is spent explaining the intricacies of the contract, most specifically the mortgage (loan) contingency clause. The purchaser is directed not to have the lender rush the issuance of the commitment unless it is a firm commitment not subject to any conditions or contingencies. The consequences of a commitment that does not actually commit may cause the triggering of a default if the transaction is not completed by the purchaser. It is certain that in a transaction where the seller refuses to return the deposit, the purchaser will not simply walk away from her money; litigation will almost certainly follow. For those real estate agents who are acting as buyer's agents, you are a fiduciary to your client and therefore held to a higher standard. Any representations you may have made to the purchaser concerning the mortgage process may determine whether you will be named in a lawsuit should the purchaser attempt to recoup her deposit from the seller so direct yourself accordingly.
Alfred M. Fazio, Esq.
Capuder Fazio Giacoia LLP 
90 Broad Street 
New York, N.Y.  10004-2627  
212-509-9595

Saturday, January 12, 2019

Emily Blunt & John Krasinski Buy $11M Brooklyn Heights Condo / L Train / Brooklyn Heights Condos / Brooklyn Navy Yard's Wegmans to Open / Staten Island - Coney Island New Ferry Service

Insert alt text here
Emily Blunt and John Krasinski buy $11M Brooklyn Heights condo
The couple purchased two adjacent units that can be combined to create a full-floor residence.
Insert alt text here
In Brooklyn Heights, condos on former library site launch sales from $1.088MThe 38-story building will bring a new Brooklyn Public Library branch, along with 133 apartments, to the neighborhood.
Insert alt text here
Brooklyn Navy Yard’s massive Wegmans to open this fallThe 74,000-square-foot supermarket will create 500 jobs
Insert alt text here
NYC Ferry will launch service to Staten Island, Coney IslandThe ferry service will hit all five boroughs by 2020
Insert alt text here
Brooklyn renters saved $6.4M thanks to L train shutdown hypeNorth Brooklyn renters who signed 2018 leases are the biggest winners in wake of the L shutdown cancelation.
Insert alt text here
Cuomo’s new L train plan will get independent review, says ByfordThe NYCT president said he will not be "steamrolled" into rushing a review of the suddenly-announced plan
Insert alt text here
5 Listings in Williamsburg to check outCheck out apartments asking from $639,000 to $1.15 million.

CALL / EMAIL ME! I'M HERE FOR ALL YOUR REAL ESTATE NEEDS!
C: 212-321-0115
E: NYCTREALTY@GMAIL.COM

Fernando Branco, GRI, ABR, CNE
Lic. Assoc. Real Estate Broker
Residential Real Estate
Commercial Sales & Leasing 
Graduate Realtor Institute (GRI) 
Accredited Buyer Representative (ABR) 
Certified Negotiator Expert (CNE)
R New York
641 Lexington Ave, NY NY  10022
c: (212) 321-0115

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Blogger Facebook Page Google Plus Google Plus Page 

Working by referral. Let me help you find a home too!!

JLo Lists 432 Park Condo / Best Things in NYC Now / Billionaire's One Beacon Court Relists $70M PH / UES Mansion / WV 19th Century Townhouse / Hudson Yards Performing Arts Center to Open

Insert alt text here
Jennifer Lopez and Alex Rodriguez list 432 Park condo for $17.5M
The couple purchased the apartment less than a year ago
Insert alt text here
26 best things to do in NYC right nowCurbed New York's editors have chosen the 26 places that you must visit in New York right now—the new classics, old favorites, and other essential sites.
Insert alt text here
Billionaire’s modernist One Beacon Court penthouse returns with $70M discountThe apartment, designed by Charles Gwathmey, was originally asking $115 million; now, it’s listed for $45 million.
Insert alt text here
19th-century West Village townhouse with 6 fireplaces seeks $5.95M
The home is configured as a multi-family residence but can become a single-family abode.
Insert alt text here
For $67M, an opulent Upper East Side mansion with Thierry Despont renovation
The 13,000-square-foot home has a ‘resort-style’ fitness center, among other over-the-top perks.
Insert alt text here
Hudson Yards performing arts center sets opening dateThe Shed will debut on April 5 with several notable commissions
Insert alt text here
Tracking the biggest buildings taking shape at Hudson YardsChecking in on the ambitious, multi-billion dollar megaproject.

THINKING ABOUT SELLING AND/OR BUYING IN NYC?

CALL / EMAIL ME! I'M HERE FOR ALL YOUR REAL ESTATE NEEDS!
C: 212-321-0115
E: NYCTREALTY@GMAIL.COM

Fernando Branco, GRI, ABR, CNE
Lic. Assoc. Real Estate Broker
Residential Real Estate
Commercial Sales & Leasing 
Graduate Realtor Institute (GRI) 
Accredited Buyer Representative (ABR) 
Certified Negotiator Expert (CNE)
R New York
641 Lexington Ave, NY NY  10022
c: (212) 321-0115

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Blogger Facebook Page Google Plus Google Plus Page 

Working by referral. Let me help you find a home too!!